Skip to content
← All television

The whole show

Watched Jul 3, 2026

Like the Mitchells in the final season, this show stuck around a bit longer than it needed to. That said, we got some rich performances along the way, particularly from the supporting cast, that ameliorated my issues with the back half of the series. In the end, the show (and hospitality) is about a group of people, not one chef. And I think they forgot that in the middle while also trying to communicate that this was the source of tension propelling the story. I did love watching all the characters grow and develop through their side quests, but ultimately it felt unfocused. It all looked beautiful, but tighter story editing would’ve been beneficial—and honestly, it might’ve revealed that this should’ve continued down the path of being a film (or even a film series), rather than a television show.

Season by season

Season 1 poster

Season 1

Watched
Season 2 poster

Season 2

Watched
Season 3 poster

Season 3

Watched

Watched Jun 28, 2024

It feels like this season was weirdly too focused on the craft of making good television episodes that it forgot how to make a good television season. In the end, it amounted to a collection of variably interesting vignettes with an inch of plot progression. For everything that happens, nothing happens. And it makes me wonder if we’ll get a fourth season sooner than expected — the work verges on intentionally flat enough to be setting that sort of surprise up.

Share this take
Season 4 poster

Season 4

Watched

Watched Jul 16, 2025

A marked improvement over the prior season, but still feeling very flat. I think Carmy has worn out his welcome as an unchanging character. I’m wondering if we’re nearing the end of this show’s run.

Share this take
Season 5 poster

Season 5

Watched

Watched Jul 3, 2026

A season that relies heavily on prior development while somewhat working as its own thing. Primarily focusing on the single night of service was a winning move for me—reminded me of my hospitality days and how grit and tenderness go hand in hand in the service industry. I also think there’s something about de-centering Carmy and leaning into the ensemble that works well. Unfortunately, they betray this in the finale and give us a melodramatic monologue that I didn’t care about. I so wish they had just ended with the penultimate episode, as much as I was happy for the quick glimpses of all the characters we’ve come to know. Time for a Richie and Jess spinoff.

Share this take

Episode notes

  • E1 · SodaJul 3, 2026

    Loving the rain as a character, to be honest.

  • E2 · LambJul 3, 2026
  • E3 · MintJul 3, 2026

    The air rights to ceiling collapse pipeline in full effect.

  • E4 · RibsJul 3, 2026
  • E5 · RaspberriesJul 3, 2026

    The Pastry Husbands need to stop fighting and kiss!

  • E6 · FocacciaJul 4, 2026

    I’m sick enough to watch this episode and miss my hospitality days, so there’s that.

  • E7 · CaramelJul 4, 2026

    I, too, need a shift drink and a cigarette after that. #RatatouilleMentioned

  • E8 · The Original Beef of ChicagolandJul 3, 2026

    I actually found this to be too sentimental after the penultimate episode. Obviously a great place to end the story, but I didn’t need this sappy, soapy hour-long conclusion.